In October 2019, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer signed the “Raise the Age” legislative package. This new package raises the age to 18 years old for who is considered an adult under the Michigan criminal justice system. Be advised, however, that this legislation will not go into effect until Oct. 21st, 2021. Let’s address some of the frequently asked questions surrounding the Michigan juvenile justice system.
1. How does Michigan define a juvenile?
Under current Michigan law, a person is considered an adult for purposes of the criminal law at the age of 17. So, if a 17-year-old is accused of a crime, he or she will be tried as an adult in either district or circuit court rather than in family court.
If a juvenile is 14, 15, or 16 years old and is accused of committing a felony, the prosecutor may file a motion that asks the family court to waive its delinquency jurisdiction. This is to allow the juvenile to be tried in the same manner as an adult in a court of general criminal jurisdiction.
2. Can a juvenile’s parents or guardians ever be held responsible for the juvenile’s actions?
Michigan has parental responsibility laws that impose liability on parents for the delinquent behavior of their children. These laws attempt to involve parents in the lives of their children by holding them civilly and/or criminally liable for their children’s actions.
Penalties for violation of these laws include:
- increased participation by parents in juvenile proceedings,
- financial responsibilities for restitution payments and court costs,
- financial responsibility for detention, treatment, and supervisory costs,
- participation in treatment, counseling and other diversion programs, and
- criminal responsibility and possible jail time for parents found negligent in their supervision.
3. What are delinquency proceedings?
Delinquency proceedings happen when dealing with juveniles under the age of 17 who are charged with a violation of any criminal law, criminal ordinance, traffic law, or with a status offense. Status offenses include running away from home, incorrigibility and school truancy.
Delinquency proceedings occur within the Family Division of the court system. If the juvenile is found responsible for the offense, the Family Division may order a juvenile disposition, which is an official document that details the final outcome of the case. An order of disposition includes placing the juvenile on probation or committing the juvenile to state wardship.
4. Does Michigan have juvenile jails?
There is no such thing as juvenile jail, but there are juvenile facilities that young people who break the law can be sentenced to by family court judges. Although they are not called “jail,” the juvenile facilities are locked-down facilities.
In Michigan, the treatment for juvenile crimes is to rehabilitate the young offender, while the result for adult crimes is generally punishment.
5. What happens if a juvenile is found to have committed a crime?
In the Michigan juvenile justice system, if a juvenile has been found to have committed an offense, the court may enter an order of disposition. The court has multiple options available, including:
- returning the juvenile to his or her parents,
- warning the juvenile or the juvenile’s parents and dismissing the petition,
- ordering a term of in-home probation,
- ordering the juvenile placed in suitable foster care,
- ordering the juvenile placed in, or committed to, a private or public institution or agency, and
- ordering that the juvenile satisfactorily complete a training program in a juvenile boot camp.
Understanding the Michigan juvenile justice system
It’s important to understand legal proceedings when a juvenile commits a crime. Within the Michigan juvenile justice system, parents can be held liable for the delinquent behavior of their children. And while the desired outcome of any proceeding against a juvenile is rehabilitation, the court can sentence young offenders to juvenile facilities.
Stephanie Achenbach received her Bachelor of Arts degree from Michigan State University is 1996. As a political science major, she focused on world politics and studied abroad at the University of London, London, England. Ms. Achenbach her Juris Doctor degree from Michigan State University – Detroit College of Law in 2000. Admitted to practice by the State Bar of Michigan in 2000, she is also admitted to the Federal District Court for the Eastern and Western Districts of Michigan and the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.
Ms. Achenbach began her legal career at a large firm and then returned to the Michigan Attorney General’s office, where she had clerked throughout law school. During her 10-year tenure as an Assistant Attorney General, she practiced in both the Criminal and Labor Bureaus as a trial litigator and appellate attorney. Ms. Achenbach has successfully tried hundreds of cases and drafted over 50 appellate briefs. Her appellate achievements also include an appeal from 2010 that resulted in a published Michigan Court of Appeals opinion. Today, Ms. Achenbach is a member of the Law Offices of Barton Morris, a criminal boutique law firm. As a Senior Associate, Ms. Achenbach handles state and federal criminal cases, including appeals. She also handles alcohol related driving offenses and license restitution matters.